They can be decorated for Christmas, Easter, Hannukah, St. Mix your choice of add-ins into the dough before chilling, or roll the dough logs in the jimmies or nonpariels before the second chill. Some of my favorites to add in are chocolate chunks, sprinkles, finely chopped nuts, dried cranberries, or crushed candy canes. Or you can jazz them up with sprinkles or jimmies, or any other add-ins of your choosing. You can serve them plain, just as they are, and they are so delicious. If you want a softer texture, cook it a little less. If you want it to be crunchier (though it won’t have the crumbly shortbread texture), cook it a little longer. The rich buttery vanilla flavor of these cookies is somewhere between a shortbread and a sugar cookie, with its own distinct flavor. These vanilla butter icebox cookies are the perfect cookie to make for any holiday. Peppermint meringues, iced oatmeal cookies, and of course, jam-filled thumbprints are among my favorites. All the basics.Īt Christmas, I like to add a few special holiday cookies to my cookie jar. It’s hard for me to imagine a cookie I don’t like. At least around the Holidays I don’t have to sneak around and hide my passion for cookies. If I am being totally honest, all seasons are cookie season as far as I am concerned.

Ice box cookies